Skip to content
Sign in
↑Part of: Judge blocks Justice Department effort to segregate California ballots
Politics · Global

Judge orders the US Justice Department to hand over list of alleged noncitizen voters in California

A judge ordered the Justice Department to give immigrant rights groups its list of alleged noncitizen voter registrations in California. NBC News reported that the list contains 20,000 registrations and that the deadline for turning it over is Friday.

AI-assisted synthesis · Based on 5 outlets' reporting · Article text read from 1 of 5 outletsHow it's made

View timeline · 6 entries
5 outletsLatest reporting 3 min readNo new reporting in 3 days
Coverage: Mostly CenterL 1 · C 4 · R 0
Updat3 graphic: United States
Updat3 graphic · Map data: Natural Earth Natural Earth (public domain)

What happened

Key facts

  • A judge ordered the U.S. Justice Department to hand over a list of alleged noncitizen voters in California (per NBC News, AP News, thestar.com).
  • The list concerns 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrations (per NBC News).
  • Immigrant rights groups are to receive the list (per NBC News, sfchronicle.com).
  • The deadline for the Justice Department to turn over the list is Friday (per NBC News, thestar.com, AP News).
  • Election officials have noted that many voter registrations flagged by the Justice Department appear to belong to U.S. citizens (per NBC News, thestar.com, AP News).
  • An appeals court rejected a Justice Department request for California to set aside disputed ballots (per thestar.com, NBC News, AP News).
  • A judge denied the Justice Department's bid to stop processing California ballots (per NPR, NBC News, thestar.com).

The brief

A judge ordered the U.S. Justice Department to turn over its list of alleged noncitizen voter registrations in California to immigrant rights groups. NBC News reported that the order requires the department to provide the list by Friday; the outlet’s excerpt does not specify the calendar date of that deadline.

The list contains 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrations, according to NBC News. The allegation concerns registrations, not a finding that the people listed are noncitizens or that they cast ballots unlawfully. The judge’s order requires the department to give the list to the groups, while the Justice Department had assembled the list of registrations it flagged.

The accuracy of those flags is an issue raised in the NBC News account: election officials have said many registrations identified by the Justice Department appear to belong to U.S. citizens. The excerpt does not identify those officials or provide a count of registrations they believe are associated with citizens.

It also does not state how the officials reached that assessment. The order comes as the Justice Department pursues legal efforts connected to the upcoming midterm elections, NBC News reported. The excerpt does not describe those efforts beyond the list dispute, or explain the judge’s reasoning for ordering disclosure.

It does not state what the immigrant rights groups plan to do with the information once they receive it. Other headlines describe related California election litigation, but their specific claims concern separate procedural actions. The Toronto Star headline says an appeals court rejected a Justice Department request for California to set aside disputed ballots.

NPR’s headline says a judge denied the department’s bid to stop processing California ballots. Neither headline provides details about the grounds for those decisions or establishes that they involve the same order or case as the list dispute.

The immediate next step specified in NBC News’s account is the Justice Department’s delivery of the list to the immigrant rights groups by Friday. The account does not say whether the department has complied, whether it intends to challenge the order, or what response the groups may make after receiving the list.

Why it matters

  • The order requires the Justice Department to provide immigrant rights groups with a list covering 20,000 alleged noncitizen registrations.
  • The list’s accuracy has direct stakes for U.S. citizens whose registrations were flagged: election officials said many flagged registrations appear to belong to citizens.
  • The dispute is connected to Justice Department legal efforts around the upcoming midterm elections.

What to watch next

  • Whether the Justice Department provides the list to immigrant rights groups by Friday.
  • Whether immigrant rights groups respond after receiving the list.
  • Whether the Justice Department challenges or otherwise contests the order.

How it's being covered

Coverage analysisShow details
5 source articles · 5 unique outlets
Outlet political mix: Mostly Center· 1 Left · 4 Center
Where the outlets are based: US/Canada 40% · Unknown 40% · Other 20%
Outlet political mix
Mostly Center
Left
Center
Right
1 outlet
4 outlets
0 outlets
The marker shows coverage balance: each unique outlet counts once.
Geography
Where the outlets covering this story are based.
5 unique outletsDominant coverage: US/Canada
Coverage imbalance
  • Coverage is currently concentrated among Center-rated outlets (4 of 5 rated sources); comparatively few Right-rated outlets have published on the event.
How we measure coverage

One source is from a wire service (AP, Reuters, AFP or Bloomberg), whose reporting other outlets often republish.

How outlets' accounts compare

Updat3 does not yet have enough full reports to compare how outlets framed this story.

Timeline

Developments from this story's sources, dated background we compiled and fact-checked, and our earlier coverage. Each row says which.
  1. Congress enacted the National Voter Registration Act, setting federal requirements for voter registration and maintenance of voter rolls.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  2. President George W. Bush signed the Help America Vote Act, establishing federal requirements for statewide voter-registration databases and election administration.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  3. California enacted a law requiring the Department of Motor Vehicles to register eligible customers to vote unless they declined.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  4. In 2016, San Francisco voters approved a measure allowing some noncitizen parents and guardians to vote in school-board elections; that local exception did not extend to state or federal contests.
    Background · from our historical context
  5. The Department of Homeland Security notified California Secretary of State Shirley Weber that it had identified thousands of likely noncitizens registered to vote.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  6. The deadline for the Justice Department to turn over the list is Friday.
    Reported in this story's sourcesSource:NBC News

How we got here

California’s current dispute over alleged noncitizen registrations has a precedent in the state’s 2018 motor-voter registration error. Federal law has barred noncitizens from voting in federal elections since the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 made knowingly voting in such an election a crime.

In 2016, San Francisco voters approved a measure allowing some noncitizen parents and guardians to vote in school-board elections; that local exception did not extend to state or federal contests.

Original sources

2 of 5 articles · US/Canada · Show all

Every story links to the reporting it was built from. How we choose sources

Spotted a factual error, a broken link or a misleading summary? Tell us.