Skip to content
Sign in
Geopolitics · Middle East

Pelosi says Mamdani and El-Sayed’s Israel views are wrong

Nancy Pelosi said Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed were wrong about Israel and that their views did not reflect Democrats in Congress. In a podcast discussion, Donny Deutsch called the views concerning and said he regarded denying Israel’s right to be a Jewish state as antisemitic.

AI-assisted synthesis · Based on 4 independent reports from 5 outlets · Article text read from 2 of 4 reportsHow it's made

View timeline · 11 entries
5 outletsLatest reporting 3 min read
Coverage: Mostly CenterL 0 · C 2 · R 1 · 2 unrated
Updat3 graphic: Israel
Updat3 graphic · Map data: Natural Earth Natural Earth (public domain)

What happened

Key facts

  • Nancy Pelosi called Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed’s views on Israel wrong (per New York Post, wfmd.com, meaww.com).
  • Pelosi said the views did not represent congressional Democrats (per New York Post, vinnews.com).
  • Deutsch said he considered the claim that Israel should not have the right to be a Jewish state antisemitic (per New York Post, meaww.com).
  • Pelosi said she hoped Zohran Mamdani would succeed as mayor while disagreeing with some of his statements (per New York Post, meaww.com).
  • In a June 28 interview with ABC News, Zohran Mamdani said he supported Israel as a state with equal rights but did not endorse it as a Jewish state (per New York Post, meaww.com).
  • Pelosi referred to Abdul El-Sayed as “this new person in Michigan” and said his election prospects remained to be seen (per meaww.com, New York Post).
  • Pelosi said that comments by some members could be interpreted in ways they should not be, and that House members distance themselves from such statements (per New York Post, meaww.com).

The brief

Nancy Pelosi said Zohran Mamdani and Abdul El-Sayed were wrong about Israel, adding that their views did not represent Democrats in Congress. The former House speaker made the comments during a podcast discussion with Donny Deutsch, who pressed her about antisemitism in the Democratic Party.

Deutsch said that, in his view, saying Israel does not have the right to be a Jewish state is antisemitic. Pelosi agreed that such a position was wrong. She also said she hoped Mamdani would succeed as mayor, while making clear that she disagreed with some of his statements.

The distinction between opposing Israel’s status as a Jewish state and supporting equal rights in Israel is central to the discussion. In a June 28 interview with ABC News, Mamdani said he supported Israel as a state with equal rights but did not endorse it as a Jewish state.

He said he could not support a state that privileges one religion over another, whether Israel, Saudi Arabia or elsewhere. Pelosi’s criticism addressed both Mamdani and El-Sayed, but the accounts give different emphasis to their political circumstances. The New York Post identifies Mamdani as New York City mayor and El-Sayed as a Michigan Democratic U.S. Senate candidate.

The headline from VINnews focuses on El-Sayed’s Senate candidacy and Pelosi’s assertion that the views do not reflect congressional Democrats; the headline from 930 WFMD includes both men and characterizes Pelosi’s remarks as calling their comments concerning and wrong.

Pelosi also said that when a member of the House makes such a statement, other members distance themselves from it. Her remarks set out a boundary between the views she criticized and the position she said congressional Democrats represent, without claiming that the two men’s statements spoke for the party.

The exchange leaves two distinct positions in view: Deutsch’s stated judgment that denying Israel’s right to be a Jewish state is antisemitic, and Mamdani’s stated support for equal rights alongside his refusal to endorse a Jewish-state definition. Pelosi called the views wrong, while saying she wished Mamdani well as mayor.

She described El-Sayed as a new political figure in Michigan and said it remained to be seen whether he would be elected.

Why it matters

  • The dispute concerns how Democratic political figures define support for Israel: Mamdani said he supports Israel as a state with equal rights but does not endorse it as a Jewish state.
  • Pelosi’s statement that the views do not represent congressional Democrats draws a distinction between the criticized positions and the party’s members in the House.
  • Deutsch’s claim that denying Israel’s right to be a Jewish state is antisemitic frames the exchange around the boundary between criticism of a state’s structure and antisemitism.

What to watch next

  • Whether Pelosi or other congressional Democrats further address her claim that the views do not represent them.
  • Whether Zohran Mamdani elaborates on his stated support for equal rights in Israel and his position on a Jewish-state definition.
  • Whether Abdul El-Sayed comments on Pelosi’s criticism or his views on Israel.
  • Whether Donny Deutsch continues to press Democratic figures on antisemitism in the party.

How it's being covered

Coverage analysisShow details
5 source articles · 5 unique outlets · 4 distinct reports
Outlet political mix: Mostly Center· 2 Center · 1 Right · 2 unrated
Where the outlets are based: US/Canada 100%
Outlet political mix
Mostly Center
Left
Center
Right
0 outlets
2 outlets
1 outlet
The marker shows coverage balance: each unique outlet counts once. 2 unrated outlets are not included.
Geography
Where the outlets covering this story are based.
5 unique outletsDominant coverage: US/Canada
Coverage imbalance
  • Coverage is currently concentrated among outlets based in US/Canada (5 of 5 geographically-identified sources).
How we measure coverage

How outlets' accounts compare

4 framing differences · 3 uncorroborated claims
The reports repeat the same account with different emphasis; its central claims are not independently confirmed in the reporting Updat3 read.Compared across 2 reports whose article text Updat3 read; 2 other outlets were checked by headline only.
Framing / emphasis differences
Sources emphasise different angles, actors or consequences of the same reporting.
  • The New York Post emphasizes Pelosi calling both men’s views wrong and not representative of congressional Democrats; the VINnews headline foregrounds El-Sayed’s Senate candidacy and the party-representation point.
  • The 930 WFMD headline describes Pelosi’s remarks as calling the men’s past comments both concerning and wrong, while the New York Post excerpt reports Pelosi saying the comments were more than concerning and wrong.
  • Mediaite’s headline frames the exchange as a Jewish podcaster pressing Pelosi on antisemitism in the Democratic Party.
  • Deutsch, not Pelosi, explicitly characterized denying Israel’s right to be a Jewish state as antisemitic; Pelosi called the position wrong.
Updat3: These are differences of emphasis, not disputes about what is reported. They do not show that the reported claims are true.
One-sided or uncorroborated claims
Claims that come from one party or one source family and are not independently corroborated.
  • Pelosi said Mamdani’s views were “wrong” and did not reflect congressional Democrats.
  • Deutsch said that denying Israel the right to be a Jewish state was antisemitic in his view.
  • Mamdani said he supported Israel as a state with equal rights but did not endorse it as a Jewish state.
Updat3: Not independently corroborated yet — treat as a claim, not an established fact.

Timeline

Developments from this story's sources, dated background we compiled and fact-checked, and our earlier coverage. Each row says which.
  1. The United States recognized Israel on May 14, 1948, the day David Ben-Gurion declared its independence.
    Background · from our historical context
  2. Israel captured the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Gaza, the Golan Heights and Sinai during the Six-Day War.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  3. In 1979, Egypt and Israel signed a peace treaty that led to Israel’s withdrawal from Sinai; the treaty did not resolve Palestinian claims.
    Background · from our historical context
  4. Abdul El-Sayed was born in Michigan to Egyptian immigrant parents.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  5. Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization exchanged letters of mutual recognition.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  6. Abdul El-Sayed lost the Democratic primary for Michigan governor to Gretchen Whitmer.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  7. Hamas-led fighters attacked Israel, killing about 1,200 people and taking about 250 hostages, according to Israeli authorities.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  8. Abdul El-Sayed entered the Democratic primary for Michigan’s open U.S. Senate seat.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  9. Zohran Mamdani won the New York City mayoral election.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  10. Zohran Mamdani took office as New York City mayor.
    Background · compiled and fact-checked by Updat3
  11. In a June 28 interview with ABC News, Zohran Mamdani said he supported Israel as a state with equal rights but did not endorse it as a Jewish state.
    Reported in this story's sourcesSource:news.meaww.com

How we got here

In an ABC News interview on June 28, Zohran Mamdani said he supported Israel as a state with equal rights but did not endorse its definition as a Jewish state. That distinction has a history in debates over Israel’s founding and the relationship between Jewish self-determination and equal citizenship.

The United States recognized Israel on May 14, 1948, the day David Ben-Gurion declared its independence. The 1948 Arab-Israeli war followed Israel’s declaration and the entry of neighboring Arab armies; Palestinians refer to the displacement and flight of Palestinians during that war as the Nakba.

Original sources

5 articles from 5 outlets

Every story links to the reporting it was built from. How we choose sources

Spotted a factual error, a broken link or a misleading summary? Tell us.